Hallux rigidus surgery

Offer provided by The Victor Hugo Clinic

What does the procedure involve?

Surgery for hallux rigidus aims to eliminate pain in the joint at the base of the big toe (metatarsophalangeal) when medical treatments are no longer sufficient. Depending on the degree of cartilage wear, the surgeon chooses between two approaches. They can preserve the joint by removing the bony growths that block movement. They can also replace or permanently fuse it when the arthritis is too advanced.

Indications

This procedure may be recommended in the following situations:

When to have foot or ankle surgery is an important decision; make sure it is a necessary intervention!

Available techniques and comparison

The choice of technique primarily depends on the stage of osteoarthritis, as seen on weight-bearing X-rays, and then on the patient's age, activity level, and expectations.

Cheilectomy, for early stages

Cheilectomy involves removing the osteophyte (the bony "spur") located on the top of the joint, which impinges during walking and limits movement. It is often combined with an osteotomy of the first phalanx (Moberg osteotomy) to restore upward movement. The joint is preserved.

It can be performed percutaneously, through very small incisions of a few millimeters, using motorized burrs under fluoroscopic guidance. This approach minimizes scarring, postoperative pain, and swelling. It can also be performed via open surgery through a dorsal incision of a few centimeters, which offers a direct view of the cartilage and allows for the treatment of more extensive lesions.

Arthrodesis, for advanced stages

Arthrodesis consists of permanently fixing the joint in an optimal position for walking. The worn cartilage is removed and the two bones are fused with a plate and/or screws until they merge. This is the gold standard technique for advanced osteoarthritis. It permanently relieves pain at the cost of losing movement in this joint, a loss that is generally well tolerated in daily life.

It is most often performed using a minimally invasive approach, via a reduced incision that preserves the soft tissues, or open surgery in cases of significant deformity or revision surgery.

Prosthesis and implants, in certain selected cases

The big toe prosthesis, or resurfacing implant, replaces the worn articular surfaces while preserving mobility. Its long-term results are more variable than those of arthrodesis. It is therefore reserved for specific profiles, which the surgeon discusses on a case-by-case basis during consultation.

In summary

Cheilectomy, whether percutaneous or open, preserves movement and enables rapid recovery, but is reserved for early stages and osteoarthritis may continue to progress. Arthrodesis, either minimally invasive or open, provides the most reliable and durable pain relief, with a longer recovery and permanent loss of joint movement. The prosthesis preserves mobility, but only for a more limited number of patients.

Intervention procedure

Preoperative assessment. The surgical consultation is based on weight-bearing X-rays of the foot, sometimes complemented by a CT scan. An anesthesia consultation takes place at least 48 hours before the procedure. A blood test is requested depending on your age and medical history.

Anesthesia. The procedure is most often performed under regional anesthesia (nerve block at the ankle or behind the knee), possibly combined with mild sedation. The foot remains numb for several hours after the operation, which limits pain during the first few hours. Learn more: Anesthesia in foot surgery [to be created].

Duration. Allow about 30 minutes for a cheilectomy and 45 minutes to one hour for an arthrodesis or a prosthesis.

Hospitalization. The procedure is performed on an outpatient basis: you return home the same day.

Postoperative periods, from D0 to D90

The same day (D0). You leave with a postoperative shoe with a rigid sole and painkillers. During the first few days, keep your foot elevated as much as possible to reduce swelling. Depending on your profile, a preventive anticoagulant treatment may be prescribed.

First to third week. After a cheilectomy, weight bearing is allowed immediately in the postoperative shoe. Gentle self-mobilization exercises of the big toe should be started quickly, according to the surgeon's instructions, to maintain the improvement in mobility. After an arthrodesis, weight bearing is done in a specific postoperative shoe, often with forefoot offloading. The dressing is changed by a nurse and the stitches are removed around day 14 if they are not absorbable.

Three to six weeks. After a cheilectomy, returning to a wide and soft shoe is generally possible by the third or fourth week. After an arthrodesis, the postoperative shoe is usually kept for about six weeks, until the follow-up X-ray confirms bone healing.

Six weeks to three months. Gradual return to normal footwear. The foot may remain swollen at the end of the day for three to six months: this is normal and will subside over time.

Sick leave. For a cheilectomy, allow about two to three weeks for a sedentary job and four to six weeks for a standing or physical job. For an arthrodesis, allow four to six weeks for a sedentary job (remote work is often possible sooner) and two to three months for a physical job.

Find all our instructions on the After Foot Surgery page [to be created].

Rehabilitation and resumption of activities

Rehabilitation. After a cheilectomy, a few sessions of physical therapy help recover mobility of the big toe and restore a normal gait pattern. After an arthrodesis, rehabilitation is lighter and focuses mainly on walking and balance.

Walking. Walking is possible from the first day in the postoperative shoe. Normal, limp-free walking usually returns within one to three months depending on the technique used.

Driving. If the operated foot is the left and your vehicle has an automatic transmission, you may resume driving as soon as the pain allows. For the right foot, allow about three weeks after a cheilectomy and six weeks after an arthrodesis. In all cases, wait until you can brake firmly and without pain.

Sports. Using a stationary bike and swimming are generally possible from the fourth week after a cheilectomy and the sixth week after an arthrodesis, once the incisions are closed. Running and impact sports can usually be resumed around two to three months after a cheilectomy and three to four months after an arthrodesis.

Shoes. After an arthrodesis, moderate heels (about 3 to 4 cm) remain possible, but high heels are not recommended.

Expected results and success rate

In the early stages, cheilectomy relieves the vast majority of patients, with reported satisfaction rates of around 70 to 90% in the literature. However, osteoarthritis may continue to progress. An arthrodesis remains possible at a later stage if the pain returns.

Arthrodesis achieves bone fusion in more than 90% of cases and provides lasting pain relief in nearly 9 out of 10 patients. It is considered the reference technique for advanced stages.

The final result can be assessed between six months and one year, the time it takes for the swelling to disappear completely.

Risks and complications

Like any surgery, the procedure involves risks. They are rare but should be known:

Your surgeon will detail these risks during the consultation according to your situation. See also: Complications of foot surgery [to be created].

Rates, excess fees and coverage

Hallux rigidus surgery is a procedure reimbursed by Health Insurance, based on standard rates. The surgeons at the practice work in [sector to be specified]. Excess fees may apply, both for the surgeon and the anesthetist, and are often covered in full or in part by your supplementary health insurance depending on your contract.

A detailed estimate will be provided to you during the consultation. You can then submit it to your health insurance provider before the procedure and find out your possible out-of-pocket costs. Clinic fees (ambulatory room, package) are subject to separate information from the establishment.

[Indicative fee range to be completed by the practice, if desired]

For any questions, contact the practice or make an appointment on Doctolib.

Frequently Asked Questions

Regional anesthesia makes the foot numb for the first few hours, and an appropriate pain management treatment takes over. The pain is generally moderate and well controlled. It decreases significantly after the first week, especially if you keep your foot elevated. The percutaneous technique is usually the least painful.

Plan on average two to three weeks off after a cheilectomy for office work, and four to six weeks after an arthrodesis. For standing or physical jobs, the recovery time can range from six weeks to three months depending on the procedure.

You will walk as early as the day of the surgery with the postoperative shoe. Returning to a normal shoe usually happens around three to four weeks after a cheilectomy and about six weeks after an arthrodesis. Smooth, comfortable walking typically returns between one and three months.

It all depends on the condition of the cartilage. If the joint is still well preserved, cheilectomy allows you to keep movement. If the arthritis is advanced, arthrodesis provides the most reliable relief from pain. The choice is made during the consultation, supported by x-rays.

This is possible in some cases, especially for percutaneous cheilectomies. However, this makes the first few weeks more restrictive. Your surgeon will discuss this with you based on your lifestyle.

Yes. Most patients resume athletic walking, hiking, cycling, or running, sometimes at an even better level than before since the pain is gone. Only sports requiring significant big toe flexion may remain limited.